💬
The Michaels Group
Hi 👋 How can we help you today?

Reliable, Personable,

& Prompt Insurance

Let us do the shopping for you! You can have the experts check for free.

About Us

A Full-Service Insurance Team That Actually Picks Up

When you’re shopping for insurance, you don’t want delays, automated systems, or a message telling you someone will call back in 72 hours. You want clear answers, straightforward options, and a team that handles the details without passing you around. The Michaels Group is a 20–25 person independent insurance team, and when you call during business hours, you speak directly with a member of our team — available until 9:00 PM on weekdays and 5:00 PM on weekends, with all after-hours inquiries returned by 8:00 AM the next business day. We provide same-day quotes and same-day certificates, and we proactively manage your account so you’re never left chasing paperwork or wondering what comes next.

25+

Insurance Carriers

1000+

Happy Clients

24/7

Support Available

About Us

A Full-Service Insurance Team That Actually Picks Up

When you’re shopping for insurance, you don’t want delays, automated systems, or a message telling you someone will call back in 72 hours. You want clear answers, straightforward options, and a team that handles the details without passing you around. The Michaels Group is a 20–25 person independent insurance team, and when you call during business hours, you speak directly with a member of our team — available until 9:00 PM on weekdays and 5:00 PM on weekends, with all after-hours inquiries returned by 8:00 AM the next business day. We provide same-day quotes and same-day certificates, and we proactively manage your account so you’re never left chasing paperwork or wondering what comes next.

25+

Insurance Carriers

1000+

Happy Clients

24/7

Support Available

Our Services

Insurance Solutions That Keep You Moving

Personal Insurance

Protecting your home, vehicles, and family can feel complicated when policies are full of fine print. We compare options across carriers and explain coverage clearly, so you know exactly what you’re getting and why it fits your life.

Learn More

Commercial Insurance

Business owners don’t have time to chase certificates or wait days for answers. Our team delivers same-day certificates, responsive service seven days a week, and structured account management that keeps your coverage aligned with your operations.

Learn More

Business Insurance

Business insurance protects your company from financial loss caused by property damage, liability claims, employee risks, and other unexpected events. It provides the coverage your business needs to operate confidently, meet contractual requirements, and stay financially secure.

Learn More

Policy Reviews & Coverage Audits

Many people discover gaps only after a claim. We proactively review your policies, identify overlaps or blind spots, and recommend adjustments before small issues become expensive surprises.

Learn More

Our Team

The Agents Behind The Michaels Group

Our team is trained both internationally and locally, so they understand your needs and the environment in which you do business. 

Jesse Michaels

Agency Owner

Email Me (631) 629-2233

Alana Nelson

Senior Insurance Advisor

Email Me (631) 418-8384

Katya Macek

Senior Insurance Advisor

Email Me (386) 218-1329

Lisa Miller

Customer Service Representative

Email Me (386) 267-0509

Christian Harrelson

Restaurant & Nightlife Insurance Specialist

Email Me (386) 230-9498

Case Studies

Real Results for Real Clients

See how we've helped businesses and families achieve comprehensive protection and peace of mind.

Commercial Insurance

Restaurant Protection Package

Comprehensive coverage solution for a growing restaurant chain, including liquor liability, property, and workers compensation.


  • 40% cost savings
  • Complete coverage
  • Streamlined claims

Personal Insurance

Family Asset Protection

Tailored insurance portfolio for a family including home, auto, life, and umbrella coverage with coordinated policy management.


  • Unified coverage
  • Better rates
  • Peace of mind

Business Insurance

Commercial Fleet Coverage

Custom commercial auto and trucking insurance for a logistics company with 50+ vehicles and specialized cargo needs.


  • Fleet optimization
  • Risk reduction
  • 24/7 support

Testimonials

What Our Clients Say

Don't just take our word for it. Here's what our valued clients have to say about their experience.

X. G

Mark Sharifi

Eric HILL

Ellen Miller

Mildred Rodriguez

Get Started Today

Ask Us Anything, We’d Love To Answer!

Florida Office:

1119 N Dixie Freeway, New Smyrna Beach, Florida 32168

386-274-8150


New York Office:

425 New York Avenue, Huntington, New York 11743

(631) 629-2233

Contact Us